Greg's Note: Have we learned nothing from the 1970s? The Fed has set us on a path toward inflation that may save some jobs in Washington, but lead our dollar into a black hole. Adrian Ash reminds us of some of history's important lessons, lest we be doom to repeat them. Perhaps two dissenting voters know more than the rest of us. Enjoy, and send your comments to the managing editor here: greg@whiskeyandgunpowder.com Whiskey & Gunpowder
— John Ehrlichman, assistant to President Richard Nixon, SO WE'RE ALL AGREED, THEN. "This is clearly the worst financial problem we've had since the Great Depression," as Joseph Stiglitz said on a radio show in New Zealand on Wednesday morning. (He's there attending a conference.) The Nobel-winning economist lined up behind Countrywide Financial (July '07), Wells Fargo (November '07), former Treasury adviser Nouriel Roubini (December '07), the National Association of Homebuilders (March '08), and pretty much everyone else in saying this is as bad as it gets. As in, the worst ever — like finding nothing besides Of Mice and Men to order from Amazon and nothing but Seabiscuit to rent at Blockbuster. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~Special~~~~~~~~~~~~~ A Minor Correction… A Major Bull We've seen the price of gold ease in the last few days. The market does this from time to time. It's called a correction, nothing more. Now that a few big banks have sugarcoated their losses, some investors are filing out of commodities. The door for more gains is now open. With the price much lower than it was a month ago, now is an even better time to get into the gold markets. Click here to find out five great plays to make… ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ The men now pulling the Fed's monetary levers sure agree. And while Ben Bernanke might see the shadow of depression where the rest of us glimpse a shade, liquidating the malinvestments of 2002-2007 is certainly hurting. Imagine the U.S. Treasury paid your wages each month; you'd jump to increase the money supply every chance you got, too. See, it's the only way to stop the Nazis from taking over. Or the commies. Or maybe even — oh, horror! — the Democrats... "Involuntary unemployment," as John F. Kennedy put it way back in 1962, "is the most dramatic sign and disheartening consequence of underutilization... We cannot afford to settle for any prescribed level of unemployment." Barely a generation after the worst recession in U.S. history, backing labor over capital like this — and thereby nabbing labor's far weightier vote — meant JFK got to kick Richard Nixon around at the ballot box. When his turn at the top finally came around at the end of the '60s, Tricky Dick didn't forget the kicking. In fact, "I [already] knew from bitter experience how, in both 1954 and 1958, slumps which hit bottom early in October contributed to substantial Republican losses in the House and Senate," as Nixon himself wrote in 1962. So come December 1968, when Herbert Stein first met with Nixon as head of his Council of Economic Advisers — and Nixon asked Stein to name the biggest problem they faced — "I started with inflation," said the economist. "[Nixon] agreed, but immediately warned me that we must not raise unemployment," Stein was to recall nearly 15 years later. "I didn't at the time realize how deep this feeling was or how serious its implications would be..." Fast-forward to the brink of Easter '08, and the "serious implication" of the Great Depression once again is the cost of not acting to prevent it. Or so everyone says. And I mean everyone... "[The liquidationists] turned the 1930 recession into a slump," says Ambrose Evans-Pritchard for The Daily Telegraph here in London:
~~~~~~~~~~~~~Special~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Turn $200 into $30,000 While the market is evaluating its appetite for risk, many investors are shying away from small companies. Some small-cap companies with great potential for gains are actually seeing their share prices fall. Sounds like the perfect time to get in. Right now, even the smallest investment in a tiny company can set you up for huge gains in the near future. Click here to learn a system proven to work… ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Better anything — even a bailout of Wall Street's hated bankers today — than jackboots and Benzedrine addicts with Chaplin moustaches, right? And where better to start in getting the voters onside than with Ben Bernanke's complete collection of The Waltons, seasons 1-9, on DVD...?
"During the major contraction phase of the Depression, between 1929-1933," as Bernanke said in a speech in 2004, "real output in the United States fell nearly 30 percent. "During the same period, according to retrospective studies, the unemployment rate rose from about 3 percent to nearly 25 percent, and many of those lucky enough to have a job were able to work only part time." By comparison, the 1973-75 recession — "perhaps the most severe U.S. recession of the World War II era," according to Ben "John-Boy" Bernanke — real output fell 3.4 percent and the unemployment rate merely doubled, from four percent to nine percent. So never mind about the double-digit inflation. Never mind that by the end of the '70s, "every business decision [had become] a speculation on monetary policy," as J. Bradford DeLong put it in a 1996 essay. Never mind that business can't function if money becomes a flickering variable, making the trade-off between inflation and jobs...bailouts and growth...a loser both ways. "Other features of the 1929-33 decline included a sharp deflation," Bernanke went on in his speech, soup ladle in hand and a Baker Boy flat cap on his head, "prices fell at a rate of nearly 10 percent per year during the early 1930s — as well as a plummeting stock market, widespread bank failures, and a rash of defaults and bankruptcies by businesses and households." So no matter the cost, deflation must be defeated long before it arrives. Indeed, the higher the cost, the better! "In 1938, Congress enacted the Fair Labor Standards Act," writes David Hackett Fischer in The Great Wave — his sweeping review of history's longest inflations — "which set the first national minimum wage. It also briefly considered a maximum wage, but that idea was quickly forgotten." Over the next 30 years, this upward bias in wages — all floor and no ceiling — was "built into the American economy," Hackett Fisher goes on. "Floors under wages, pensions, and compensation for the unemployed; floors beneath farm prices, steel prices, liquor prices, and milk prices; floors for airline fares, trucking charges, doctors' bills, and lawyers' fees..." Come Nixon's first term, the high cost of living was mandated by government, corporations, unions, and householders alike. Falling prices could not be allowed ("You remember the '30s, don't you?") and — as yet — rising prices were no more than a puzzler at the grocery store every Saturday morning. Convinced by economists of a trade-off between rising prices and jobs, governments everywhere watered and tended inflation, thinking they could always prune it if the foliage got out of control. And feeding its roots, deep below ground, was the rich, manure mulch of the Great Depression. "At the surface level," DeLong explains, the destruction of money during the '70s happened because no one in power "placed a high enough priority on stopping inflation." Worse than that, Nixon and his successors — Gerald Ford and then Jimmy Carter — inherited "painful dilemmas with no attractive choices." The '60s battle to grow jobs at the expense of sound money had already locked in that problem. But at the very deepest level, "the truest cause of the 1970s inflation was the shadow cast by the Great Depression," DeLong concludes. "It took the 1970s to persuade economists and policymakers that 'frictional' and 'structural' unemployment were far more than 1-2 percent of the labor force. It took the 1970s to convince [them] that the political costs of even high single-digit inflation were very high." In short, the developed world balked at the chance to "liquidate labor, liquidate stocks, liquidate the farmers, liquidate real estate" — as U.S. Treasury Secretary Andrew Mellon had urged in the '30s — when the liquidation wouldn't have washed so deep or so hard at the start of the '70s. Scared by the ghost of a Greater Depression instead, the West pushed ahead with big budget deficits, negative real interest rates, and a destruction of money that almost bankrupted Treasury bond holders. The runaway inflation that failed to back off when Richard Nixon nudged the Fed about defending jobs before the dollar (for what else is "inflation" if not a loss of purchasing power?) proved a hard-won lesson all told. Reaching double digits across the developed world and causing a flight into commodities that in turn led to a huge bubble of malinvestments in the early 1980s, the "sustained spurt" of '70s inflation equaled the worst wartime price increases by the time double-digit interest rates could be used — with broad voter approval — to kill it off. It all ended — guess what! — with a forced liquidation at the start of the '80s. And today? "Ben Bernanke is smarter than I am and thinks about this 24/7, which I do not," says Bradford DeLong on his blog this week. "He leads a superb committee. He is backed by the best monetary policy technical economic staff in the world. If I disagree with Ben's FOMC on an issue of monetary policy, I am probably wrong." Either that, or Bernanke's still stuck on Walton's Mountain nostalgia...just as TV audiences were back in the '70s. Regards, Greg's Endnote: Along with Ed Bugos' Gold and Options Trader, the team at Outstanding Investments is also coming up with great ways for you to play the volatile commodities market. For years, investors have used commodities as a safe haven from the stock market. With some guidance, you could be making big gains in resource stocks while the rest of the market tries to catch up. Click here to see what they're working on… |
Whiskey & Gunpowder Special Reports $1000 Gold and Rising... 5 Entirely New Ways To Play the Gold Trend The 10 Shocking Reasons for China's Pollution Problem Geothermal Energy: Investment in the Future Here's One Coal Stock That's Set to Skyrocket Investing in Exchange Traded Funds The Real Story Behind the True Gold Bull Market If someone forwarded you this copy, please look here to start your own subscription. Wanna let us know what you thought of today's issue? Now you can... click on this link. Whiskey & Gunpowder is a free e-mail service brought to you by a team of rebellious brigands. If you have not already done so, please click here to confirm your subscription. This will help us ensure you get every Whiskey & Gunpowder without interruption. Are you having trouble receiving your Whiskey & Gunpowder? You can ensure its arrival in your mailbox here. Please note: we sent this e-mail to lemmetry@gmail.com because you subscribed to this service. To end your Whiskey & Gunpowder e-mail subscription, click here. Nothing in this e-mail should be considered personalized investment advice. Although our employees may answer your general customer service questions, they are not licensed under securities laws to address your particular investment situation. No communication by our employees to you should be deemed as personalized investment advice.We expressly forbid our writers from having a financial interest in any security recommended to our readers. All of our employees and agents must wait 24 hours after on-line publication or 72 hours after the mailing of a printed-only publication prior to following an initial recommendation. Any investments recommended in this letter should be made only after consulting with your investment advisor and only after reviewing the prospectus or financial statements of the company. © 2008 Agora Financial, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Protected by copyright laws of the United States and international treaties. This newsletter may only be used pursuant to the subscription agreement and any reproduction, copying, or redistribution (electronic or otherwise, including on the World Wide Web), in whole or in part, is strictly prohibited without the express written permission of Agora Financial, LLC. 808 Saint Paul Street, Baltimore MD 21202. |
